Compare workers' comp insurance

Compare workers' comp insurers and state funds, then see who must carry it, how premium is calculated and where higher-risk businesses can get coverage.

Workers' comp insurers and state funds

Some insurers quote online in minutes; others sell through agents. In Ohio, North Dakota, Washington and Wyoming you must buy from the state fund. Tick the ones you want quotes from, then press Request quotes.

9 shown

The Hartford

Online quote

Free online quote

Offers pay-as-you-go billing based on actual payroll. Source

NEXT Insurance

Online quote

Buy online in about 10 minutes

Covers more than 1,300 professions; share certificates at no extra cost. Source

Pie Insurance

Online quote

Online quote in about 3 minutes

Small business workers' comp in 40 states and Washington, DC. Source

biBerk

Online quote

Instant online quote

A Berkshire Hathaway company that sells direct, without a broker. Source

Travelers

Through an agent

Through an independent agent

Says it is the nation's largest workers' comp insurer. Source

EMPLOYERS

Through an agent

Through an agent

Small business workers' comp specialist operating nationwide except the four state-fund-only states. Source

AmTrust

Through an agent

Through a local agent

Workers' comp is one of its three core small business products. Source

State Compensation Insurance Fund (California)

State fund

Quote from State Fund

Created by the California legislature in 1914; committed to covering all California businesses. Source

Texas Mutual

State fund

Through an agent

Describes itself as Texas's leading workers' comp provider and reports $5.1 billion in policyholder dividends. Source

Listed for comparison only, not an endorsement. Prices change, so confirm on each company's site.

Is it required?

Workers' comp for private employers is set by each state. The U.S. Department of Labor keeps a directory of state workers' compensation officials where you can check your state.

How it's priced

  1. Each job is assigned a classification code with a state-approved rate per $100 of payroll. Roofing costs far more than clerical work.
  2. Payroll in each class is divided by 100 and multiplied by its rate, then the classes are added.
  3. The total is multiplied by your experience modification factor (mod).

A mod of 1.00 is average. Below 1.00 lowers premium and above raises it: 0.75 cuts it by 25% and 1.25 raises it by 25%. If you don't yet qualify for experience rating, you get 1.00.

Where to get coverage

SourceNotes
Private insurerBought directly or through a licensed agent or broker. Working with a broker
State fundSome states run one. California's State Compensation Insurance Fund is a nonprofit state-operated insurer and the insurer of last resort.
Self-insuranceFor large employers. California requires state approval, at least $5 million net worth and $500,000 annual net income, plus a security deposit.
PEOMany PEOs cover clients under their own policy. How PEO workers' comp works

Higher-risk and hard-to-place businesses

In California? See PEOs for healthcare and hard-to-place businesses in California.

Workers' comp through a PEO

A PEO can bundle workers' comp with payroll and benefits, often billed per pay period. Upload your declarations page with a quote request and PEOs can price your exact classes.

Get workers' comp quotes through PEOsSchedule a discovery call

Questions

Is workers' comp required?

It depends on the state. California requires every employer with one or more employees to provide it. Texas lets private employers choose not to carry it, but those non-subscribers have notice and reporting duties.

How is workers' comp priced?

Insurers apply a state-approved rate for each job classification per $100 of payroll, add the classifications together and multiply by your experience modification factor.

What is an experience mod?

A number that compares your actual losses with expected losses for similar businesses. 1.00 is average; 0.75 cuts premium by 25% and 1.25 raises it by 25%. New businesses without enough history get 1.00.

Where can a hard-to-place business get coverage?

Options include insurers that write your class, a state fund where one exists (California's State Compensation Insurance Fund is its insurer of last resort), and some PEOs that cover your classifications under their policy.

Sources

General information, not legal, tax, insurance or financial advice. Rules change, so confirm with the agency or a licensed professional.